9 OKC Desserts We Can’t Pass Up

This is the time of the year when everyone seems to have a little more of a ‘sweet tooth’. If you are anything like me, you may live life according to the motto of “life’s short, eat dessert first!” We have compiled a list of nine local desserts that are sweet to enjoy all year round so indulge! Let us know what you think.

Bourbon Street Cafe | Bricktown OKC

100 E California Ave., OKC, OK 73104

Bourbon St. Cafe is a little taste of New Orleans right here in the metro. With their value of southern hospitality, great tasting food and fun cocktails; they have something for everyone to love while in a festive environment. After enjoying a fancy plate of seafood or a casual burger; you cannot leave without getting their signature New Orleans Bread Pudding! It’s is a favorite of Yay Dude OKC’s Chief Storyteller Malena Putnam. Bread Pudding is a staple in New Orleans, LA; and this sweet comfort food is AMAZING.

Open 7 days a week.

Phone: (405) 232-6666

La Baguette Bistro | Oklahoma City

7408 N May Ave., OKC, OK 73116

La Baguette has been a staple in OKC for many years and is a destination for those seeking great French food and their top-notch bakery! Their bakery is one-of-a-kind as it is surrounded by an art gallery featuring Oklahoma artists. One of their most popular bakery item is their Chocolate Mousse Cake. It is a rich and soft cake topped with sprinkles and chocolate ruffles. This cake comes in 6″, 8″, 10″ and 12″ and is worth every bite. Promise.

Open 7 days a week.

Phone: (405) 840-3047

Eddies | Edmond

2828 E Second St., Edmond, OK 73034

Eddie’s is a locally owned scratch kitchen that offers a fun and inviting atmosphere. They provide quality ingredients, friendly service and large portion sizes. However, you must save room for their Salted Caramel Brownie! It is a gourmet salted caramel brownie, drizzled with salted caramel & dark chocolate on a unique chocolate covered pretzel crust. Chocolate lovers, this one’s for you!

Open 7 days a week.

Phone: (405) 285-7725

Not Cho Cheesecake | Bethany

3933 N College Ave., Bethany, OK 73008

Not Cho Cheesecake’s can be described as “Cheesecake Heaven”. They are a locally owned and operated bakery in Bethany, but their tasty dessert is eaten all over the country. They take many pre orders and ship freshly baked cakes to your door, whether you are local or not! A favorite is their Tennessee Whiskey Cheesecake. It is topped with a homemade caramel sauce and can be made to-order with or without peanuts. This bold, sweet and delicious cheesecake will have you singing Chris Stapleton all day long!

Hours: Tues – Fri: 12pm-7pm | Sat: 12pm – 4pm

Phone: (405) 782-0880

Railyard Pie | Edmond

19 W First St; Unit 150., Edmond, OK 73003

Representing “family, community and togetherness” this new company in the Edmond Railyard has stolen the hearts of many around the metro. They are a small-locally owned business that excels in making freshly baked pies in the heart of bringing people together. They have a store-front on the north side of the Railyard and still have days they are sold out of pies in the early afternoon so just try whatever they have in stock or you can pre-order to guarantee to get your hands on these pies. The double-crust apple pie is um, double crusted!, and, as you can see, isn’t stingy on the apple goodness. This would be a great addition to your holiday gatherings. Order early!

Hours: Tues – Sat: 10am – 8pm

Phone: (405) 920-6192

Cafe 501 | Classen Curve, Edmond

Cafe 501 is a part of the Holloway Restaurant Group that has been operating and serving Edmond for over two decades. Cafe 501 is known for its modern style, casual dining and bakery. They have a wide variety of desserts to choose from but the go-to for our MVP, Tracy Morris of Edmond Family Eye Care is their vanilla cupcake. She describes it as “perfect”. I mean, just take a peek in that case! So hard to choose…

Open 7 days a week.

Classen Curve phone: (405) 844-1501

Edmond phone: (405) 359-1501

McLarens Pantry | Edmond

3414 S Blvd., Edmond, OK 73103

McLaren’s Pantry has been an Edmond favorite since 1984! They are a family-owned deli and bakery and continuously create delicious baked goodies and food; all while maintaining a family and community atmosphere. Tracy Morris of Edmond Family Eye Care highly recommends their signature no bake cookies, lemon squares, and Hello Dollys!

Hours: Mon – Fri: 10am – 6pm & Sat – 10am – 4pm

Phone: (405) 348-2336

ButterSweet Cupcakes | Edmond, Yukon

ButterSweet is a family owned cake shop that has been featured on “Bake it Like Buddy” on Discovery+ and has a ‘passion for fresh’. This is my, (Sarah’s), personal go-to for a dessert. I have been going here for many years now and every sweet treat I get from here has never disappointed. However, my overall pick and favorite is their Cookie Dough Cupcake. The soft cake base is complimented by the icing that is pretty much like edible cookie dough! Stop by and get one, or a dozen. 😉

Hours: Mon – Sat: 11am – 7pm

Yukon phone: (405) 265-4994

Edmond phone: (405) 397-9395

Charleston’s | OKC (etc.)

Charlston’s is a part of Hal Smith Restaurant group and is a loved-staple restaurant for many. Within the metro they have six locations and many beyond and in the state. With a variety of different food and menu choices, there is one thing that many people have in common within selections at Charleston’s. Their beloved key lime pie is a fan-favorite and a ‘must-get’. It provides a creamy and tangy flavor all on top of a crisp crust, which is key lime perfection in our book.